Last week Neal Williams and I published two articles on Baseball Analaysts related to quantifying third base coaching here and here. In those articles we showed the results for 2006 as well as the aggregates for all coaches from 2000 through 2006. In the interest of full disclosure here are the results for all individual coach seasons from 2000 through 2006 ordered by the Ratio of the "coach influenced" Rate to the "non-coach influenced" Rate. So Tom Foley, under this version of the measure, recorded the top two seasons.
Year Team Name Opp OA EqHAR Rate Opp OA EqHAR Rate Ratio
2006 TBA Tom Foley 163 1 5.3 1.15 313 12 -6.6 0.80 1.44
2003 TBA Tom Foley 225 6 6.0 1.14 378 12 -8.4 0.80 1.42
2004 PIT John Russell 200 5 1.5 1.04 347 8 -9.2 0.74 1.41
2000 BOS Wendell Kim 229 6 -2.0 0.96 306 13 -10.1 0.69 1.38
2000 TBA Billy Hatcher 194 3 0.5 1.01 285 12 -6.8 0.75 1.36
2001 TBA Billy Hatcher 193 3 4.6 1.10 288 9 -5.5 0.82 1.34
2003 PHI John Vukovich 245 2 2.7 1.05 381 13 -8.1 0.80 1.31
2001 TOR Terry Bevington 202 4 0.4 1.01 239 5 -5.3 0.77 1.31
2003 SFN Gene Glynn 208 4 2.2 1.05 371 8 -6.7 0.82 1.29
2002 BOS Michael Cubbage 217 6 2.0 1.05 316 9 -5.2 0.82 1.28
2005 PHI Bill Dancy 265 10 -4.4 0.93 408 12 -10.1 0.74 1.24
2005 HOU Doug Mansolino 188 5 -3.3 0.93 383 12 -8.7 0.75 1.24
2001 DET Lance Parish 189 5 0.9 1.02 243 8 -3.7 0.84 1.22
2003 HOU Gene Lamont 224 5 2.2 1.05 386 13 -6.3 0.86 1.22
2004 OAK Ron Washington 262 7 -1.0 0.98 366 6 -6.3 0.81 1.22
2005 TOR Brian Butterfield 233 2 7.1 1.15 389 11 -1.5 0.95 1.21
2000 OAK Ron Washington 271 7 -1.3 0.97 293 10 -5.7 0.81 1.21
2001 ATL Ned Yost 208 7 3.1 1.07 244 11 -2.7 0.89 1.20
2000 NYN Cookie Rojas 221 5 -0.2 1.00 268 9 -4.6 0.83 1.20
2004 PHI John Vukovich 245 10 -1.9 0.96 348 9 -6.9 0.80 1.20
2006 PHI Bill Dancy 262 5 7.8 1.15 329 5 -1.2 0.96 1.20
2003 BOS Michael Cubbage 277 6 2.7 1.04 390 6 -5.9 0.87 1.20
2004 SEA Dave Myers 253 6 -1.2 0.98 396 6 -7.2 0.82 1.20
2006 BAL Tom Trebelhorn 296 3 0.3 1.01 400 8 -6.1 0.84 1.20
2004 DET Juan Samuel 230 5 5.0 1.10 344 8 -2.4 0.92 1.19
2002 SEA Dave Myers 217 3 1.8 1.05 318 10 -4.0 0.88 1.19
2002 SFN Sonny Jackson 173 6 -4.9 0.86 301 11 -7.0 0.73 1.19
2002 ARI Eddie Rodriquez 243 6 -0.4 0.99 266 11 -4.0 0.84 1.18
2002 BAL Tom Trebelhorn 146 4 2.4 1.10 249 11 -1.6 0.94 1.18
2000 SLN Jose Oquendo 242 6 6.3 1.13 250 5 -0.8 0.96 1.17
2002 MON Manny Acta 188 3 5.1 1.12 249 11 -1.0 0.95 1.17
2005 SDN Rob Picciolo 234 5 -1.6 0.97 370 12 -6.2 0.83 1.17
2004 NYN Bobby Floyd 173 5 -2.7 0.93 316 8 -6.0 0.81 1.15
2004 BOS Dale Sveum 295 8 -8.6 0.86 409 8 -11.2 0.75 1.15
2000 PIT Jack Lind 211 2 4.7 1.10 273 10 -0.9 0.96 1.14
2001 FLO Fredi Gonzalez 172 2 2.5 1.07 278 5 -2.0 0.94 1.14
2005 MIN Al Newman 219 5 1.2 1.03 392 8 -3.6 0.90 1.14
2000 TEX Jerry Narron 271 2 10.9 1.18 322 4 1.2 1.04 1.13
2004 HOU Gene Lamont 217 5 1.4 1.03 398 12 -3.6 0.91 1.13
2006 SFN Gene Glynn 220 3 -2.2 0.95 346 6 -4.7 0.84 1.13
2005 CLE Joel Skinner 213 2 6.8 1.15 365 9 0.7 1.02 1.13
2000 CHN Gene Glynn 253 9 -6.3 0.89 230 5 -4.9 0.79 1.12
2004 ARI Al Pedrique 223 2 5.3 1.11 308 4 -0.3 0.99 1.12
2001 BOS Gene Lamont 188 7 -6.3 0.84 291 11 -6.6 0.75 1.12
2002 MIN Al Newman 211 6 0.0 1.00 267 8 -2.9 0.89 1.12
2003 DET Juan Samuel 197 4 2.3 1.06 249 7 -1.0 0.95 1.11
2002 TOR Carlos Tosca 214 4 0.5 1.01 324 7 -2.7 0.91 1.11
2001 COL Rich Donnelly 248 5 7.3 1.13 249 7 0.5 1.02 1.10
2001 CIN Ron Oester 189 5 -0.3 0.99 263 14 -2.5 0.90 1.10
2003 MON Manny Acta 238 5 1.3 1.03 332 9 -2.5 0.93 1.10
2002 CLE Joel Skinner 200 4 -0.4 0.99 252 8 -2.2 0.90 1.10
2000 NYA Willie Randolph 271 6 -0.4 0.99 287 6 -2.2 0.90 1.10
2003 CHN Wendell Kim 198 7 -6.1 0.85 339 13 -6.7 0.78 1.10
2003 FLO Ozzie Guillen 186 5 2.7 1.07 374 10 -0.9 0.98 1.09
2006 CLE Jeff Datz 274 5 -0.7 0.99 400 7 -3.4 0.91 1.09
2006 SDN Glenn Hoffman 231 4 -0.2 1.00 348 7 -3.2 0.91 1.09
2002 LAN Glenn Hoffman 199 5 3.2 1.08 258 8 -0.1 0.99 1.09
2001 ANA Ron Roenicke 237 1 7.7 1.15 253 8 1.2 1.06 1.09
2006 TOR Brian Butterfield 237 6 -0.4 0.99 387 9 -2.9 0.92 1.08
2004 TEX Steve Smith 230 3 3.7 1.08 339 6 0.0 1.00 1.08
2000 ARI Brian Butterfield 268 7 2.2 1.04 246 9 -0.9 0.96 1.08
2000 HOU Mike Cubbage 244 7 -1.3 0.97 310 8 -2.8 0.91 1.08
2000 TOR Terry Bevington 237 8 -3.8 0.92 305 6 -3.9 0.86 1.08
2006 NYN Manny Acta 228 3 2.3 1.05 293 4 -0.6 0.98 1.07
2000 CLE Jim Riggleamn 270 7 -2.0 0.96 308 11 -3.5 0.90 1.07
2002 MIL Gary Allenson 169 10 -4.2 0.86 269 13 -5.0 0.81 1.07
2005 NYN Manny Acta 196 2 4.2 1.11 300 8 1.0 1.04 1.07
2000 SDN Tim Flannery 221 6 5.2 1.12 209 4 1.0 1.05 1.07
2004 CLE Joel Skinner 259 7 6.7 1.11 383 8 1.8 1.05 1.06
2005 PIT John Russell 228 7 -1.5 0.97 408 10 -3.8 0.91 1.06
2001 CLE Joel Skinner 206 8 0.3 1.01 308 7 -1.8 0.95 1.06
2001 SEA Dave Myers 254 3 7.5 1.14 347 10 3.0 1.07 1.06
2003 SEA Dave Myers 262 4 -0.4 0.99 402 9 -2.5 0.94 1.06
2006 MIL Dale Sveum 214 5 0.3 1.01 329 11 -1.7 0.95 1.06
2006 ANA Dino Ebel 238 3 10.3 1.19 373 9 5.2 1.13 1.06
2003 NYN Matt Galante 197 6 1.5 1.04 324 7 -0.3 0.99 1.06
2006 CHA Joey Cora 234 9 -7.7 0.86 404 9 -7.5 0.81 1.05
2006 COL Mike Gallego 247 3 1.5 1.03 359 12 -0.8 0.98 1.05
2001 CHA Gary Pettis 175 6 -1.0 0.97 241 6 -1.7 0.93 1.05
2006 OAK Ron Washington 245 7 -4.9 0.89 372 10 -6.0 0.85 1.04
2005 BAL Tom Trebelhorn 205 7 -2.6 0.94 356 7 -3.3 0.91 1.04
2006 WAS Tony Beasley 239 6 1.5 1.03 314 9 -0.3 0.99 1.04
2001 OAK Ron Washington 241 7 2.7 1.05 250 4 0.4 1.02 1.04
2003 MIL Rich Donnelly 194 9 -6.1 0.87 330 8 -5.8 0.83 1.04
2003 LAN Glenn Hoffman 236 6 -2.1 0.96 278 4 -2.2 0.92 1.04
2004 BAL Tom Trebelhorn 263 7 0.7 1.01 434 13 -0.9 0.98 1.04
2003 ATL Fredi Gonzalez 244 6 1.2 1.02 415 8 -0.4 0.99 1.04
2000 ATL Ned Yost 211 8 -4.8 0.90 278 10 -3.3 0.87 1.04
2004 ANA Ron Roenicke 258 7 1.0 1.02 408 12 -0.3 0.99 1.03
2005 OAK Ron Washington 275 2 8.7 1.15 376 2 4.9 1.12 1.03
2002 DET Doug Mansolino 209 8 3.3 1.08 213 6 1.1 1.06 1.03
2002 SDN Tim Flannery 238 8 -1.6 0.96 236 9 -1.2 0.94 1.03
2001 SDN Tim Flannery 224 4 2.9 1.06 265 7 1.0 1.04 1.02
2001 NYA Willie Randolph 216 1 4.7 1.11 227 6 1.7 1.08 1.02
2002 CHN Gene Glynn 204 6 -5.5 0.85 244 7 -3.4 0.84 1.02
2006 KCA Luis Silverio 237 4 2.0 1.04 400 13 0.7 1.02 1.02
2004 CHA Rafael Santana 202 4 3.3 1.08 361 8 2.3 1.06 1.02
2002 NYA Willie Randolph 243 3 4.1 1.10 283 11 2.0 1.08 1.02
2005 DET Juan Samuel 199 2 0.0 1.00 383 8 -0.6 0.98 1.02
2005 SLN Jose Oquendo 247 3 4.3 1.08 383 7 2.2 1.06 1.02
2005 MIL Rich Donnelly 205 6 -0.8 0.98 337 12 -1.2 0.97 1.02
2002 SLN Jose Oquendo 217 4 5.6 1.16 266 6 3.2 1.14 1.02
2003 BAL Tom Trebelhorn 234 2 5.9 1.12 401 7 4.5 1.11 1.02
2005 ARI Carlos Tosca 223 3 -0.4 0.99 313 5 -0.6 0.98 1.01
2005 SFN Gene Glynn 229 3 1.0 1.02 342 7 0.4 1.01 1.01
2004 TBA Tom Foley 230 4 -1.2 0.98 304 6 -0.9 0.97 1.01
2004 MIN Al Newman 208 3 3.7 1.08 350 7 2.3 1.08 1.01
2006 BOS DeMarlo Hale 248 5 -7.6 0.86 424 8 -7.6 0.85 1.01
2003 TOR Brian Butterfield 231 2 -0.1 1.00 425 11 -0.5 0.99 1.01
2005 NYA Luis Sojo 315 7 -3.0 0.95 347 8 -1.4 0.95 1.00
2005 TEX Steve Smith 201 2 1.9 1.04 330 6 1.3 1.04 1.00
2000 CHA Bryan Little 264 4 7.5 1.14 298 5 4.6 1.14 1.00
2002 TEX Steve Smith 213 4 0.3 1.01 272 6 0.1 1.01 1.00
2000 SFN Sonny Jackson 228 6 -2.1 0.95 318 8 -1.8 0.95 1.00
2003 COL Sandy Alomar 228 4 6.5 1.13 344 7 5.3 1.13 1.00
2002 FLO Ozzie Guillen 159 5 -1.4 0.95 258 9 -1.2 0.96 0.99
2002 CIN Tim Foli 169 6 0.5 1.01 212 8 0.5 1.02 0.99
2005 WAS Dave Huppert 240 4 -0.7 0.99 318 7 -0.2 1.00 0.99
2002 ANA Ron Roenicke 280 7 0.0 1.00 314 5 0.3 1.01 0.99
2003 NYA Willie Randolph 246 10 -1.0 0.98 392 10 -0.3 0.99 0.99
2000 MON Pete MacKanin 201 5 0.4 1.01 228 8 0.5 1.02 0.99
2001 SLN Jose Oquendo 210 6 9.1 1.19 241 7 4.2 1.21 0.98
2004 SLN Jose Oquendo 236 2 6.5 1.13 375 8 5.1 1.14 0.98
2000 CIN Ron Oester 218 6 -0.7 0.98 308 6 0.1 1.00 0.98
2004 FLO Jeff Cox 194 6 0.8 1.02 353 9 1.4 1.04 0.98
2005 KCA Luis Silverio 212 5 3.7 1.08 387 6 3.8 1.10 0.98
2002 CHA Gary Pettis 204 8 -2.1 0.94 268 8 -0.7 0.97 0.98
2004 ATL Fredi Gonzalez 222 4 1.5 1.03 375 5 1.9 1.06 0.97
2006 SEA Carlos Garcia 226 6 -1.5 0.97 377 13 -0.2 1.00 0.97
2005 CHA Tim Raines 204 9 2.9 1.06 335 7 3.2 1.10 0.97
2000 PHI John Vukovich 233 7 -2.1 0.96 260 7 -0.2 0.99 0.97
2002 TBA Tom Foley 205 5 -2.0 0.95 276 6 -0.2 0.99 0.96
2004 SDN Rob Picciolo 253 4 4.4 1.09 416 8 5.2 1.13 0.96
2005 TBA Tom Foley 233 4 5.8 1.13 338 7 7.6 1.18 0.96
2003 ARI Eddie Rodriquez 232 5 -5.6 0.88 348 5 -2.7 0.92 0.96
2000 COL Rich Donnelly 296 5 6.7 1.12 315 4 6.0 1.17 0.96
2006 SLN Jose Oquendo 230 5 -1.1 0.98 375 9 1.0 1.03 0.95
2005 CIN Mark Berry 227 5 0.2 1.01 306 5 1.8 1.06 0.95
2001 BAL Tom Trebelhorn 179 9 -0.2 1.00 261 5 1.4 1.05 0.95
2001 CHN Gene Glynn 217 3 -2.0 0.96 268 5 0.2 1.01 0.95
2006 ARI Carlos Tosca 275 6 0.5 1.01 332 5 2.0 1.07 0.95
2006 DET Gene Lamont 240 5 5.0 1.10 362 3 5.5 1.16 0.95
2005 COL Mike Gallego 241 5 -0.2 1.00 369 7 2.3 1.06 0.94
2003 CLE Joel Skinner 209 6 2.2 1.05 342 9 4.2 1.12 0.94
2000 MIN Ron Gardenhire 274 7 -2.9 0.95 256 6 0.3 1.01 0.94
2006 NYA Larry Bowa 289 5 -4.1 0.93 410 3 -0.2 1.00 0.94
2006 PIT Jeff Cox 230 3 -1.2 0.98 399 2 1.8 1.04 0.93
2003 KCA John Mizerock 249 4 0.3 1.01 432 8 3.4 1.08 0.93
2002 HOU Gene Lamont 234 6 -0.5 0.99 293 10 1.8 1.06 0.93
2004 LAN Glenn Hoffman 211 4 4.1 1.09 321 3 4.5 1.17 0.93
2001 LAN Glenn Hoffman 199 6 -4.4 0.89 219 8 -0.9 0.96 0.92
2002 PIT Trent Jewett 173 4 1.3 1.04 248 4 2.7 1.13 0.92
2004 COL Sandy Alomar 259 7 5.2 1.09 339 8 7.3 1.19 0.92
2006 LAN Rich Donnelly 260 9 -6.0 0.90 370 10 -1.0 0.97 0.92
2000 KCA Rich Dauer 300 6 -0.6 0.99 332 6 2.6 1.08 0.92
2005 LAN Glenn Hoffman 244 9 -9.5 0.79 339 12 -4.8 0.86 0.92
2006 CIN Mark Berry 217 5 -0.8 0.98 315 4 2.4 1.08 0.91
2005 SEA Jeff Newman 207 4 2.7 1.07 359 3 6.1 1.17 0.91
2003 TEX Steve Smith 204 7 -1.6 0.96 346 7 2.1 1.06 0.91
2006 HOU Doug Mansolino 214 1 5.6 1.11 344 1 7.6 1.23 0.91
2006 TEX Steve Smith 234 5 -2.5 0.95 410 9 2.5 1.06 0.90
2001 PHI John Vukovich 225 9 -3.6 0.92 236 5 0.5 1.02 0.90
2001 MIN Ron Gardenhire 237 9 2.6 1.05 223 7 4.0 1.17 0.90
2000 FLO Fredi Gonzalez 191 4 1.6 1.04 241 4 3.9 1.16 0.90
2003 CIN Tim Foli 218 7 -1.7 0.96 290 7 2.4 1.07 0.90
2004 KCA John Mizerock 229 6 -1.3 0.97 358 5 2.9 1.09 0.90
2004 CHN Wendell Kim 197 7 -6.5 0.83 335 8 -2.8 0.93 0.89
2001 MON Jeff Cox 202 6 -2.6 0.93 221 4 0.9 1.04 0.89
2005 FLO Jeff Cox 221 8 -7.1 0.84 411 7 -2.9 0.94 0.89
2003 PIT John Russell 244 7 -1.5 0.97 341 6 3.1 1.09 0.89
2001 PIT Trent Jewett 181 6 1.2 1.03 206 6 3.5 1.16 0.89
2006 ATL Fredi Gonzalez 231 6 -3.3 0.94 362 6 2.5 1.06 0.89
2006 MIN Scott Ullger 222 3 0.5 1.01 452 8 6.6 1.14 0.88
2005 ANA Ron Roenicke 271 7 0.1 1.00 355 5 4.5 1.13 0.88
2005 BOS Dale Sveum 280 5 -12.6 0.77 463 7 -5.7 0.88 0.87
2003 OAK Ron Washington 227 8 -1.1 0.98 345 5 5.3 1.12 0.87
2000 MIL Chris Speier 216 7 1.3 1.03 242 2 4.4 1.19 0.86
2003 CHA Rafael Santana 206 4 -2.6 0.95 356 4 3.7 1.10 0.86
2002 OAK Ron Washington 209 7 -1.2 0.97 270 3 2.5 1.12 0.86
2001 NYN John Sterns 206 10 -7.0 0.85 253 10 -0.4 0.98 0.86
2004 MON Manny Acta 182 4 2.4 1.07 321 5 7.5 1.24 0.86
2001 KCA Rich Dauer 211 6 -1.9 0.96 269 5 3.3 1.12 0.86
2001 MIL Gary Allenson 197 8 -8.4 0.76 241 6 -3.0 0.89 0.85
2004 TOR Brian Butterfield 226 7 -2.7 0.94 380 5 3.8 1.11 0.85
2001 SFN Sonny Jackson 200 8 -9.6 0.77 277 5 -3.1 0.91 0.85
2006 FLO Bobby Meacham 199 4 2.3 1.05 359 5 8.3 1.24 0.84
2003 SDN Rob Picciolo 217 2 1.2 1.03 377 4 7.8 1.22 0.84
2000 SEA Larry Bowa 206 5 -4.6 0.89 289 6 2.3 1.07 0.83
2005 ATL Fredi Gonzalez 189 3 0.2 1.00 334 4 8.0 1.21 0.83
2002 KCA Rich Dauer 199 8 2.7 1.06 260 5 6.8 1.28 0.83
2003 MIN Al Newman 251 10 -3.4 0.93 375 5 5.3 1.13 0.83
2002 COL Rich Donnelly 201 7 3.0 1.08 260 8 6.7 1.31 0.82
2002 PHI John Vukovich 182 5 -2.5 0.93 266 7 3.2 1.14 0.82
2003 ANA Ron Roenicke 234 8 -2.4 0.95 363 1 6.1 1.17 0.82
2004 CIN Mark Berry 240 8 -10.3 0.78 290 8 -1.1 0.96 0.81
2001 ARI Chris Speier 216 4 -0.1 1.00 239 5 5.7 1.24 0.80
2000 DET Doug Mansolino 256 4 2.0 1.04 320 1 9.7 1.30 0.80
2001 TEX Jerry Narron 223 6 -3.2 0.93 289 8 5.3 1.17 0.79
2000 LAN Glenn Hoffman 221 8 -4.6 0.90 256 5 4.0 1.14 0.79
2002 NYN Matt Galante 193 4 -3.0 0.93 254 10 5.3 1.18 0.79
2004 SFN Gene Glynn 263 12 -7.2 0.87 397 2 4.2 1.11 0.78
2006 CHN Chris Speier 199 6 -2.9 0.94 350 3 7.2 1.22 0.77
2001 HOU Matt Galante 202 9 -7.3 0.83 275 9 2.3 1.08 0.77
2005 CHN Chris Speier 229 5 -2.9 0.94 327 5 6.8 1.23 0.77
2004 NYA Luis Sojo 243 9 -3.2 0.93 371 4 7.2 1.22 0.76
2000 ANA Ron Roenicke 258 10 -3.6 0.94 284 3 6.5 1.24 0.76
2000 BAL Sam Perlozzo 254 5 -4.0 0.92 275 3 6.3 1.22 0.75
2003 SLN Jose Oquendo 234 7 -4.8 0.90 377 7 8.3 1.22 0.74
2004 MIL Rich Donnelly 190 7 -8.8 0.79 315 3 2.1 1.07 0.73
2002 ATL Ned Yost 171 6 -6.7 0.79 275 3 6.1 1.23 0.65
There was some discussion of the "smell test" and how it related to "Waving" Wendall Kim and so here are his seasons chronologically.
Year Team Name Opp OA EqHAR Rate Opp OA EqHAR Rate Ratio
2004 CHN Wendell Kim 197 7 -6.5 0.83 335 8 -2.8 0.93 0.89
2003 CHN Wendell Kim 198 7 -6.1 0.85 339 13 -6.7 0.78 1.10
2000 BOS Wendell Kim 229 6 -2.0 0.96 306 13 -10.1 0.69 1.38
In 2003 and 2004 he performed about the same (and negatively) but in 2003 the team in non-coach opportunities performed even more poorly. The same holds true for his 2000 season with the Red Sox. This points to the fact that perhaps we should be weighting the coach opportunities differently from the non-coach and as pointed out by MGL perhaps all advancements to home plate should be considered coach opportunities.
125x125_10off+copy.jpg)
No comments:
Post a Comment